Monetary policy across the world is guided by flawed monetary theory that puts the cart before the horse, i.e., gets the direction of causality wrong, contends former chief economic advisor K V Subramanian, who is the executive director for India on the board of International Monetary Fund, in his latest book co-authored with K Vaidyanathan – Money: A Zero-Sum Game. Edited excerpts from an interview with ET’s Deepshikha Sikarwar:
Central Banks have time and again relied on monetary stimulus to support and boost the economy. Your book questions the move’s effectiveness?
A key postulate of monetary theory, which central banks use for conventional monetary policy, is the concept of “money multiplier.” It captures the magnitude by which money multiplies through deposit and loan transactions among banks and their customers. Monetary theory posits that the money multiplier equals the reciprocal of the reserve ratio mandated by the central bank.
Yet, using several instances across the OECD economies and India, we show that central banks decreased the reserve ratio and yet the multiplier decreased instead of increasing. A second postulate that has driven unconventional monetary policy post the global financial crisis (GFC) is that releasing bank reserves would encourage banks to lend. During GFC, total bank loans decreased in the US despite bank reserves increasing 170 times! Even in India, FM Pranab Mukherjee kept lamenting “Despite the loosening of the cash reserve ratio (CRR) limits, bank credit has been steadily declining.” So, two key postulates that dictate monetary policy have had little effect on the real economy.
Such incorrect perceptions stem from flawed monetary theory. We develop an equation that we call the V-S equation to comprehensively capture all the determinants of money supply, of which central bank’s equity is one. Who funds this equity? It is the government.
India is already undergoing this shift to a higher growth path because of the sagacious economic policy implemented in COVID, where we undertook measures to enhance both supply and demand along with structural reforms. Just as turning up the AC thermostat in a room takes a few hours to heat the room, economic outcomes today result from implemented 2-3 years back. That’s why you see that at a time when the advanced economies are facing the twin whammy of 2.5-4 times their historical inflation and a recession, India is likely to grow at 7% with inflation lower than our historical average of 7%. I don’t recall another period where India was such a positive outlier on both counts – growth and inflation.
If we start from the GDP identity Y=C+I+G+(X-M), consumption (C) is mostly domestic, and it accounts for about 60% of GDP (Y). Government spending (G) is a choice variable and will continue to be robust as our fiscal space is comfortable.
